COVID 19 - Clinical Picture in the Elderly Population: A Qualitative Systematic Review
Neumann-Podczaska Agnieszka, Al-Saad Salwan R, Karbowski Lukasz M, Chojnicki Michal, Tobis Slawomir, Wieczorowska-Tobis Katarzyna
Table 1 Symptoms, Comorbidities, Radiological Findings, and Outcome.
Wang L et al. [10]Zhu X et al. [11]Lian J et al.
[12]
*Cheng B et al.
[13]
*Cheng B et al. [13]Chen T et al. [14]Liu K et al. [15]Godaert L et al.
[16]
Liu Y et al.
[17]
Mi B et al.
[18]
Publication Month - 2020MarMarMarAprAprAprMarAprMarApr
CountryChinaChinaChinaChinaChinaChinaChinaFranceChinaChina
No. Patients ≥60 Years Old339114136675155181776
Age>60>70≥60≥60≥60≥65≥60>67>61>75
Male No.166675822313412842
Symptoms+ (%)
(92)
Fev
(82)
Fev
(85)
Fev
(74)
Cgh
(83)
Fev
(95)
Fev
(78)
Fev
(77)
Fev
(100)
Fev
(84)
Fev
(53)
Cgh
(60)
Cgh
(63)
Cgh
(60)
Fev
(64)
Cgh
(70)
Cgh
(33)
Cgh
(70)
Cgh
(100)
Cgh
(84)
Cgh
(41)
Dysp
(46)
Dysp
(36)
SP
(57)
CT
(64)
CT
(64)
CT
(33)
SP
(65)
Dysp
(58)
Chi
(67)
Dysp
(40)
Ft
(45)
Ft
(18)
Ft
(48) Ft/Mya(56) Ft/Mya(60)
Dysp
(17)
N/V
(59)
Ft/Mya
(43)
Ft/Mya
(67)
Ft/Mya
(28)
Anx
(33)
SP
(15)
Mya
(36)
SP
(48)
N/V
(20)
Mya
(11)
CT
(53)
Del
(14)
Dh
(50)
ST
(28)
SP
(9)
Dh
(13)
ST
(21)
N/V
(26)
SP
(10)
Ft
(11)
Dysp
(36)
Dh
(14)
N/V
(33)
Dizz
Others(26) CT
(13) Dh
-(13) Dysp (8) Dh
(6) Hdc
(14) Hdc (14) Diz(12) Hdc
(12) Diz (6) Dh (10) Con (6) AG
(10) Anx
(6) Hdc (6) Dh (6) AP
(11) Ft/Mya (6) NC(18) SP-(17) Hdc
(17) N/V (17) NC (17) CP (17) AP
≤5 %Mya, Hdc,
N/V, Diz, Pha
Mya, N, V, PhaNC, HpDh, AG-N/V, CP----
Comorbidities++ (%)
(41)
HTN
(54) CVD(39) HTN(59) HTN(50) HTN(39) HTN(46) Smo-(58) CVD(50)
OP
(16)
DM
(22) CLD(18) DM(17) DM(32) DM(22) DM(28) HTN-(43) HTN(33) HTN
(16)
CVD
(22)
PS
(6) Smo(17) CVD(24) CVD(20) CVD(17) DM-(29) CRD(17) DM
(7)
CLD
(20)
CBD
-(10) CLD(12) CLD(15)
CBD
(17) CVD-(14) DM(17) CLD
(7)
CBD
(19)
ED
-(6) CRD(13) CLD(6) CHD-(14) CLD(17) CVD
Others-----(10) Mal (6) CRD---(17) ND
(17) BI (100) fracture patients
≤5 %CHD,
CRD, Mal, AD
MalCLD, CVD, CRD, CHD, Mal, ICCRD, CHD, Mal-CHD,
TB
----
Radiological findings (%)
Description °--(43)
GGO
--(24)
PE
---(100)
GGO/ Cons
Single (S)/Multiple (M) lobe lesions--(42) M--(98) M(89) M
(11) S
--(100) M
Distribution
Unilateral (U)/ Bilateral (BI)--(42) Bi
(11) U
--(98)
Bi
(11)
U
---
Central (C) / Peripheral (P)/ Both----------
Outcome No. (%)
Healed/Discharged91 (27)87 (60)31 (23)67 (100)--17
(95)
---
Hospitalized183 (54)-13 (10) °°------2
(33)
Death65 (19)27 (24)--51 (100)19 (35)1
(6)
--4
(67)
Days of Hospital Stay Duration - Median (IQR)28 (15-28)----12 (1-45)----
Niu S et al. a
[19]
Kerpel A et al.
[20]
Graselli G et al.
[21]
Zhu T et al.
[22]
Chen Z et al.
[23]
Guo T et al. [24]**Sun H et al. [25]**Sun H et al. [25]Bruno G et al.
[26]
Gold J et al. [27]
Publication Month - 2020AprAprAprMarMarMayMayMayMayMay
CountryChinaIsraelItalyChinaChinaChinaChinaChinaItalyUSA
No. Patients ≥60 Years Old603961282010512312131117
Age≥6560-62≥61>60≥60≥ 60≥ 60≥ 60≥65≥65
Male No.34378316-48518219-
Symptoms+ (%)
(79)
Fev
(100) Fev-(86)
Fev
-(67) Fev(85)
Fev
(89)
Fev
(81)
Fev
-
(57)
Cgh
(67) Cgh-(47)
Cgh
-(65) Cgh(74)
Cgh
(73)
Cgh
(81)
Cgh
-
(30)
Dysp
(67) Ft/Mya-(33) Ft/Mya-(33)
Ft
(39)
GiS
(33)
GiS
(48)
Dysp
-
(24) Ft/Mya(33)
NC
-(29)
Dysp
-(30) Dysp(29)
Dh
(30)
Dh
(19)
Ft
-
(7)
Hdc
(33)
Syn
-(22)
Dh
-(10)
Dh
----
--(22)
AP
-(8)
Mya
----
Others-----(6)
N/V
----
≤5 %-----Hdc,
Anx
APAPGiS,
AP
-
Comorbidities++ (%)
(48) HTN(67) HTN(38) HTN--(44)
HTN
(55)
HTN
(63)
HTN
(87)
HTN
(86)
HTN
(29) CLD(67) Smo(18) CVD--(26)
DM
(20)
DM
(22)
DM
(26)
Smo
(47)
CVD
(16) CVD(33) DM(16)
HC
--(16)
CVD
(12)
CVD
(17)
CLD
(16)
CLD
(44)
DM
(10)
DM
(33) CVD(14) DM--(12)
Smo
-(17)
CVD
(16)
CVD
(21)
CKD
(6)
CBD
(33)
PS
(8) Mal--(9)
CLD
--(13)
DM
(19)
CLD
Others-(33)
DL
(15)
NS
-----(9)
CKD
-
≤5 %--CLD, CRD, CHD--CLD,
CKD
CLD,
CBD
-MalSmo,
Mal
Radiological findings (%)
Description °-(67)
Cons
-(89)
GGO/ Cons (54) GGO (22) Cons (7) PE
-(40)
GGO
--(65)
GGO/Cons (32) Cons
-
Single (S)/Multiple (M) lobe lesions-(100) M-(93)M
(7) S
(65)M(89)M----
Distribution
Unilateral (U)/ Bilateral (BI)-(100)
Bi
--(65)
Bi (35) U
(89)
Bi (1) U
--(96)
Bi (3) U
-
Central (C) / Peripheral (P)/ Both-(67) P-(60) P
(36) Both
------
Outcome No. (%)
Healed/Discharged23
(38)
1
(33)
111 (12)--90
(86)
123
(100)
-7
(23)
65
(56)
Hospitalized32
(53)
2
(67)
525 (55) °°--12
(11)
--18
(58)
16
Death5
(9)
-322 (34)--3
(3)
-121
(100)
6
(19)
36
(31)
Days of Hospital Stay Duration - Median (IQR)-----17
(13-23)
--23
(16-30)
10
(6-16)